Home / Mattresses / How to Choose a Mattress

How to Choose a Mattress

Choosing a mattress comes down to a short list of decisions: the size, the type, the firmness and how you sleep. Each decision narrows the choice, and together they leave you with a small set of mattresses worth testing. This guide walks through the decisions in order, so you can choose on the construction and the fit rather than on a label.

Summary Verdict

Work through size, type and firmness in that order, then test the mattress lying down. The right choice is the one that fits your body and your room, not the one with the longest list of features.

Best for

Anyone replacing a mattress or buying a first one.

Sleepers who want a clear order to the decisions.

Watch out for

Firmness labels differ between brands, so test before you trust the label.

A mattress that suits one person may not suit a partner.

Start with size

Size is the first decision, because it is fixed. Measure the inside of the bed frame, not the old mattress, because an old mattress may have compressed or spread over time. Then check the room: allow space on at least one side for getting in and out, and space at the foot to walk past. A mattress that fits the frame but fills the room will annoy you every day.

Think about who sleeps in the bed. A single suits one sleeper, a double suits a couple in a standard room, and a king suits a couple who want more room. Taller sleepers should check the length as well as the width: a standard length of 190 centimetres suits most adults, but some ranges offer 200 centimetres. Our guide to mattress sizes lists the standard measurements in full.

Choose the type

The type sets how the mattress responds when you lie on it. Memory foam softens with body heat and moulds around you, giving a slow, sinking feeling and absorbing movement well. Pocket sprung mattresses use individual springs that move on their own, giving a responsive, lively feel and good airflow. Latex is firm and springy, and hybrids combine a spring core with a foam top layer.

There is no best type, only a type that suits how you sleep. If you move a lot in the night, a spring mattress is easier to turn over on. If you want movement absorbed, memory foam does that best. If you sleep hot, a sprung mattress lets more air through. If you are unsure, a hybrid is a reasonable middle ground, because it combines the support of springs with the surface feel of foam.

Match firmness to your weight

Firmness is not a property of the mattress alone: it depends on your weight. A heavier person presses further into the surface, so the same mattress feels softer to them than to a lighter person. A lighter person may find a medium mattress firm, because they do not weigh enough to sink into it. This is why firmness labels are only a starting point, and why lying on the mattress matters more than reading the label.

As a rough guide, lighter sleepers often suit a softer or medium mattress, average-weight sleepers often suit a medium, and heavier sleepers often suit a medium-firm or firm. These are starting points, not rules, and your sleeping position changes them. Side sleepers usually need a little more give, while back and stomach sleepers often prefer a firmer surface.

Match firmness to your sleeping position

The way you sleep changes what your body needs. Side sleepers put most of their weight on a shoulder and a hip, so they need a surface that gives a little at those points while still supporting the waist. Back sleepers spread their weight more evenly and usually suit a firmer surface that keeps the lower back supported. Stomach sleepers need a surface that stops the hips sinking, which usually means a firmer feel.

Most people change position during the night, so the position you fall asleep in is not the whole story. A mattress that works for your main position and is comfortable in the others is the practical target. If you share a bed, remember that two people rarely share the same weight and position, so a medium firmness is the usual compromise, or a mattress with different firmness on each side.

Size is fixed, type sets the feel, and firmness depends on your weight. Work through them in that order and the choice narrows quickly.

Test the mattress properly

A few minutes lying on a mattress in a shop is better than no test at all, but it needs to be done properly. Lie in your usual sleeping position, not on your back if you sleep on your side. Give it several minutes, because a mattress feels different after your body has settled into it. Bring the pillow you use at home if the shop allows it, because the pillow changes how your neck and shoulders sit.

Try turning over, and try sitting on the edge to check the edge support. If you share a bed, test it together, because a mattress that suits one person may not suit the other. Ask the shop how long the returns period is, because a mattress needs more than a few minutes to judge properly. A week or two of sleeping on it at home tells you far more than any shop test.

The base and the frame

The base underneath the mattress is part of the system. A mattress on a solid base feels firmer than the same mattress on slats, and a sprung base adds a little give of its own. When you test a mattress in a shop, the base it sits on is part of what you are feeling, so ask what base it is on if the feel matters to you.

At home, check that the base is sound, flat and the right size. Slats should be close enough together to support the mattress without it dipping between them, and a broken slat should be replaced before the new mattress goes on. A mattress cannot compensate for a frame that dips or creaks, and a good mattress on a poor base will feel like a poor mattress.

FeatureMemory foamPocket sprungHybrid
FeelSlow, mouldingResponsive, springySupportive with a soft top
MovementAbsorbed wellSome transferModerate transfer
HeatCan feel warmGood airflowBetter than foam alone
Turning overHarderEasierModerate

What to check before you pay

Before you buy, check the practical details. Ask about the returns period and whether there is a charge for returning the mattress. Ask about delivery: whether it includes carrying the mattress upstairs, and whether the old mattress can be taken away. Check the guarantee, and read what it covers, rather than relying on the headline length.

Check the weight of the mattress, because a heavy mattress is hard to turn and rotate alone. Check whether it is double-sided or single-sided, so you know how to care for it. And check the depth, because a deep mattress needs deeper fitted sheets. These details are dull, but they are the ones that cause trouble after the mattress arrives.

A simple order to follow

Measure the frame and the room, then choose the size. Decide on the type by thinking about how you move in the night and whether you sleep hot. Choose a firmness as a starting point from your weight and position, then test the mattress lying down. Finally, check the returns period, the delivery and the guarantee.

If you work through those steps in order, the choice becomes manageable. There will still be many mattresses to choose from, but they will be the right kind of many: the right size, the right type and the right firmness for your body. The last step is to give the mattress a fair trial at home, and to use the returns period if it does not suit you.